Black Friday promises consumers big savings and retailers a welcome boost in sales. But with margins already stretched and shoppers increasingly questioning whether the discounts are genuine, is the annual sales frenzy still worth the trouble?

Black Friday has become something of a fixture in the British retail calendar. What began as an American import has grown into one of the biggest shopping events of the year, with retailers spending weeks preparing promotions and consumers holding off purchases in anticipation of a bargain.

In fact, calling it Black Friday almost feels misleading these days. Many retailers begin advertising offers weeks before the day itself, with some extending their promotions throughout November and into December.

For consumers, the attraction is obvious. Who wouldn’t welcome a few hundred pounds off a new television or washing machine? Particularly when household finances remain under pressure.

But for electrical retailers, especially independents, the situation is rather more complicated. How much can businesses realistically afford to discount their products? Are they attracting new customers or simply selling to people who would have bought from them anyway? And, perhaps most importantly, is all the effort actually making them any money?

Is it really a bargain?

I suspect most of us have become a little more cynical about Black Friday over the years.

There was a time when the prospect of a 40 or 50 per cent discount might have been enough to convince someone to part with their money. Nowadays, shoppers have price comparison websites and historical pricing tools at their fingertips, making it considerably easier to establish whether an offer is quite as generous as it first appears.

And the evidence suggests that scepticism is justified.

Research published by Which? last year examined 175 home, technology and health appliance deals advertised during Black Friday 2024. It found that every product analysed had been available for the same price or less at another point during the surrounding year.

That doesn’t necessarily mean the offers were misleading. Retailers run promotions throughout the year, after all. But it does rather undermine the idea that Black Friday is the one occasion when consumers can secure an exceptional deal.

Interestingly, Currys appears to have recognised this problem.

Last year, the retailer launched its ‘Our Lowest Ever Price’ campaign, promising that thousands of products included in its Black Friday promotion had never previously been cheaper at Currys.

The move followed research commissioned by the company which found that 66 per cent of consumers regarded Black Friday as a ‘con’, while 62 per cent were sceptical about the discounts being advertised.

Those are quite extraordinary figures for an event that relies so heavily on convincing people they are getting a good deal.

And when one of the UK’s largest electrical retailers feels the need to reassure shoppers that its prices are genuinely competitive, perhaps the industry ought to ask itself how Black Friday acquired such a reputation in the first place.

The cost of competing

Of course, the other side of this argument is whether retailers can afford to offer the discounts consumers have come to expect.

For independent electrical retailers, the numbers can be particularly unforgiving.

The ERT Report 2026 revealed that 47.4 per cent of surveyed retailers had experienced a slight decline in sales over the previous 12 months, while 52.6 per cent reported a slight decrease in gross margins.

With wages, business rates, energy bills and other operating costs continuing to weigh on businesses, there is not necessarily much room left for generous promotions.

Take a television selling for £1,000, which costs the retailer £800. That leaves £200 in gross profit before the cost of actually running the business is taken into account.

Offer a 15 per cent discount and the selling price falls to £850. The retailer is now making just £50 in gross profit, having sacrificed three-quarters of the original amount.

Naturally, the situation is not always that straightforward. Manufacturers can provide promotional support, retailers may negotiate better purchasing terms and certain products might be discounted specifically to clear stock.

But the underlying problem remains. Customers have grown accustomed to seeing substantial reductions, often without appreciating how little margin retailers might have to play with in the first place.

There is also a significant difference between the commercial realities facing a national chain and those of a family-run independent.

The larger retailers have considerable buying power, substantial marketing budgets and the ability to spread costs across hundreds of stores or extensive online operations.

An independent electrical retailer simply cannot afford to chase every offer advertised by the competition.

And nor should they have to.

What are other retailers doing?

Looking across the electrical retail sector, it is interesting to see how businesses have approached Black Friday.

Euronics launched its 2026 campaign on 28 October, with promotions running until 1 December across categories including laundry, refrigeration, dishwashing and televisions.

For independent Euronics members, the campaign provides an opportunity to benefit from the wider publicity surrounding Black Friday while encouraging consumers to shop with their local electrical specialist.

AO has previously promoted competitive prices across major appliance categories alongside a Black Friday price-match commitment, while Richer Sounds has used its established price-beat promise to reassure customers that they are getting a competitive deal.

Argos has also previously offered a Black Friday Price Guarantee on selected products, promising compensation if qualifying prices fell further before Christmas.

What interests me about these approaches is that retailers are increasingly selling reassurance alongside the discount.

It is no longer necessarily enough to advertise a television at £200 off. Businesses also want customers to believe that they won’t find themselves regretting the purchase a fortnight later.

And there is clearly value in that.

For independent retailers, however, I wonder whether the more sensible approach is to concentrate on what they can offer that their larger competitors cannot.

A customer might be drawn into a store by a discounted appliance, but knowledgeable staff, professional installation and reliable aftersales support could ultimately prove more valuable than shaving another £20 off the price.

It is an argument that independent electrical retailers have been making for years, and Black Friday should be no exception.

Is the publicity worth the sacrifice?

Despite all these concerns, I can understand why retailers are reluctant to turn their backs on Black Friday.

Few other occasions generate quite the same level of consumer interest.

People actively go looking for offers, compare products and, importantly, arrive with the intention of spending money.

For a retailer struggling to generate footfall, that presents an opportunity which would be difficult to ignore.

And there is a marketing benefit that goes beyond the immediate sale.

Someone who has never visited their local electrical retailer might discover it while searching for a Black Friday deal. If the experience is good, that customer could return when they next need an appliance, recommend the business to friends or use its installation and repair services.

In that respect, accepting a smaller margin on an initial purchase might be worthwhile.

The difficulty is knowing whether that is actually happening.

It is easy to celebrate a busy Black Friday weekend, particularly when sales figures are looking healthy. But how many of those customers are genuinely new? How many return? And how much profit has the business sacrificed to attract them?

A record-breaking weekend for turnover is not necessarily a record-breaking weekend for profitability.

There is also the question of whether Black Friday creates additional spending or merely changes when that spending takes place.

If a customer knows that discounts are coming in November, why would they buy a new television in October?

And if retailers begin advertising Black Friday offers weeks in advance, are they not encouraging consumers to delay purchases for even longer?

I suspect a fair proportion of Black Friday spending consists of purchases that would have happened anyway, only now at a lower price.

That is not to say the event cannot generate additional demand. A particularly attractive promotion might persuade someone to upgrade their television earlier than planned or purchase an appliance they had previously considered too expensive.

But it is worth questioning whether the industry has trained customers to wait for discounts, rather than giving them a reason to buy when they actually need something.

Does everything have to be about price?

Perhaps this is where independent retailers could approach Black Friday differently.

Instead of trying to match the most aggressive discounts on the market, why not concentrate on creating offers that make sense for the business?

A washing machine promotion could include installation or removal of the old appliance. A television purchase might come with a discounted wall-mounting service or professional setup.

There could also be opportunities to work more closely with manufacturers on exclusive bundles, additional warranties or promotional packages.

Of course, none of these things comes without a cost. Free installation is not free for the retailer, and an extended warranty still has to be funded somehow.

But there is a difference between offering customers something useful and simply cutting prices to the point where a sale is barely worth making.

I would also question whether every retailer needs to participate to the same extent.

There is nothing wrong with choosing a handful of products to promote rather than discounting an entire showroom. Equally, a retailer that decides Black Friday does not make commercial sense should not feel obliged to join in simply because everyone else is doing it.

After all, there is little point in winning a customer from a competitor if the transaction leaves you worse off financially.

Finding the balance

I don’t think Black Friday is necessarily a bad thing for electrical retail. Far from it.

At a time when businesses are having to work harder for every sale, an event that encourages consumers to visit stores and consider major purchases should be welcomed.

And for shoppers who have been saving for a particular product, a genuine discount can make a meaningful difference.

But the industry needs to be careful about the expectations it creates.

The longer Black Friday becomes, the less special it feels. The more discounts consumers see throughout the year, the harder it becomes to convince them that November offers anything particularly extraordinary.

Meanwhile, retailers are left trying to satisfy those expectations without damaging their own profitability.

I suspect the businesses that get the most out of Black Friday are not necessarily those offering the largest discounts, but those that have worked out exactly what they want the event to achieve.

For some, that might mean clearing older stock. For others, it could be introducing new customers to the business or capitalising on manufacturer-supported promotions.

And for some independents, it might mean carrying on as normal, confident that their service and reputation are worth more than a temporary reduction in price.

There is room for all of those approaches.

Ultimately, Black Friday should be an opportunity for retailers to make money, not an obligation to give it away.

Because a bargain for the customer shouldn’t have to mean a bad deal for the retailer.

Stay ahead in the Electrical Retail Industry

Never miss a beat in the world of electrical retail. Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for the latest industry news, insights, and trends – delivered straight to your inbox. Plus, receive ERT Magazine 10 times a year, bringing you the latest analysis, insights, and inspiration from across the industry.

Subscribe now: https://ertonline.co.uk/registration/